About
Legendary coal-oven pizza, worth crossing boroughs for.
Why go
- Feels like the most authentic pizza spot in the city
- Historic pizza restaurant with coal-fired pizza
- Timeless appeal
Must try
- John's original pie
- Classic cheese pizza
- Calzones
- Meatball sandwich
- Picante pie with jalapenos
Pro tips
- Walk-in only
- Go an hour before you get hungry to put your name down
- Carve your name into the seats
Good to know
- No slices, only whole pies
- Expect a line, but it moves fast
Save places like this with mio
mio turns the TikTok and Instagram travel videos you save into a map of places to go. Share a video and mio pulls out every spot in it, tips included.
The tips on this page came from travel videos people saved to mio.
Rating
4.6 / 5
Price: $20–30
Opening Hours
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–11 PM |
Phone: +1 212-243-1680