The Pastry Box

About

Giant, thin, chewy cookies with crispy edges and flaky salt.

Why go

• The best cookies you can buy at a brick-and-mortar bakery in NYC

Must try

• Quarter pound chocolate chip cookie
• Black and white cookie
• Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie
• Black cocoa cookie
• Triple chocolate cookie

Pro tips

• Cookies are always made fresh no matter what time you come here
• The cookie is on the New York Times' list of 25 essential pastries
• The owner, Tiara, is described as inspiring and sweet
• Located in the East Village
• Has two Manhattan locations

Good to know

• The shop’s owner, Tiara Bennett, sells chocolate chip cookies

Save places like this with mio

mio turns the TikTok and Instagram travel videos you save into a map of places to go. Share a video and mio pulls out every spot in it, tips included.

The tips on this page came from travel videos people saved to mio.

Save this place in mio

Rating

4.7 / 5 (231 reviews)

Opening Hours